Refine Search
Sort by
$459,900
5 Beds 3 Baths 202630708 MLS 3,328 SqFt. McKenzie Forest
Start Showing Date: 8/18/2026 Where to start with this beautiful property.... Intricate details throughout the home giving it gorgeous character, like the new built in pantry built under the stairs to the details around the open staircase. It has 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, large formal dining open to the expansive living room with a wood burning fireplace and a bonus room that has been converted into a play room.From the floors to the beams on the ceiling, the architecture is unlike all the cookie cutter homes you see anymore. This has charm, space and the land around it is remarkable. If you wanted to cut some of the trees down, you would have a view of the river, which is located just down the hill. Location, space and endless possibilities. This is one of those homes you don't see come on the market very often so don't miss your chance to see this one before it is gone.

5720 E 100 N, Monticello

Listing courtesy of McKenzie Forest from RE/MAX Aspire. 574-635-0137

$1,720,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 202630601 MLS 4,380 SqFt. Garrett Criswell
Welcome to a truly rare waterfront opportunity offering approximately 4,300 square feet, 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, 4.5 private acres, and nearly 500 feet of shoreline. Built by the same legendary craftsman responsible for constructing Tony Stewart’s personal residence, this handcrafted log-style home showcases exceptional quality and timeless design. The exterior logs were individually sourced and shipped from Montana, creating the character of a mountain lodge while offering modern construction advantages. Unlike a traditional full-log cabin, this home was engineered as a stick-built residence with authentic log accents, providing improved insulation, efficiency, structural stability, and long-term durability. Heated concrete floors throughout every level add year-round comfort and quality. Since ownership began, this estate has undergone an extensive transformation with major improvements throughout the property. Recent upgrades include professional log restoration and refinishing, replacement of compromised logs, upgraded decking, oversized gutters, custom rain chains, extended electrical service to the waterfront, hillside excavation and stabilization, extensive landscaping enhancements, and significant shoreline improvements. The outdoor living spaces are truly exceptional, featuring expansive stamped concrete and exposed aggregate hardscapes, custom walkways, handcrafted staircases, multiple gathering areas, and a breathtaking connection from the home to the shoreline. The waterfront is the centerpiece of this estate with a fully custom luxury boathouse completed in January 2026, featuring premium stone finishes, custom architectural details, TimberTech decking, multiple staircases, spacious seating areas, dual personal watercraft lifts, and a heavy-duty boat lift designed for today’s largest wake boats. Additional waterfront improvements include a new steel seawall, steel retaining wall, concrete waterfront areas with built-in fire pits, and a private custom concrete boat launch—an exceptionally rare amenity on Lake Freeman. Enjoy peaceful mornings overlooking the water, evenings by the fire, boating adventures, fishing, wildlife watching, and the unmatched privacy of your own wooded retreat. With mature trees, abundant wildlife, scenic elevated views, apple and raspberry plants, and room to explore by ATV, side-by-side, or golf cart, this property offers an experience that simply cannot be duplicated.

6105 E Us 24, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Garrett Criswell from Raeco Realty. 765-838-2785

$379,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202630433 MLS 1,926 SqFt. Shelley Molter
Better than new! This impeccably maintained 6-year-old, 3-bedroom, 2-bath, split-bedroom ranch offers 1,926 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space in one of the area's most desirable golf course settings. The open-concept floor plan is filled with natural light and features a spacious kitchen, dining, and living area that flows into a stunning sunroom complete with a gas log fireplace and picturesque views. Step outside to the open deck overlooking the Tippecanoe Country Club Golf Course and the peaceful water canal leading to Lake Shafer, the perfect setting to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind at the end of the day. The private primary suite is tucked away from the additional bedrooms, creating an ideal split-bedroom layout. Situated on a .235-acre lot, this move-in-ready home has been meticulously cared for and shows like new. If you've been searching for quality construction, low-maintenance living, and beautiful golf course views, this is one you won't want to miss! Home is sold AS-IS.

4571 E Jennings Loop, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Shelley Molter from The Real Estate Agency. Office: 765-838-1707

$169,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 202630231 MLS 832 SqFt. Cody Miller
Welcome to 713 Juanita St, professionally renovated — this low maintenance ranch home makes living easy. Situated in the heart of Monticello only moments from Lake Shafer, Lake Freeman, Lake Shore Drive-In, Indiana Beach, downtown, schools, and everything else Monticello has to offer. Sitting on a quiet dead end, corner lot, with minimal traffic — the property allows you to quickly escape the noise of the world. Updates include plush Excalibur carpets, Decorators Collection Nobelford Oak waterproof laminate wood floors, Authentique Earth Ceramic backsplash, 5" trim, high-end fixtures, and newer appliances. The exterior features a perfectly sized yard, great for entertaining while also being easy to maintain, ample parking space, 12x16 insulated shed w/ electric, and a new low profile back deck. Mature trees and shrubbery around the perimeter provide privacy and a sense of seclusion. Schedule to see it, pack your bags, and move in - this property is ready for new owners!

713 Juanita Street, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Cody Miller from Raeco Realty. 765-838-2785

$289,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 202629898 MLS 1,102 SqFt. Nathan Walts
Looking for an affordable way to enjoy the lake? This charming lake house boasts interior upgrades galore, ensuring your comfort and relaxation year-round. Step inside to a fresh, inviting atmosphere, thanks to the new paint throughout. Updated light fixtures illuminate the space, creating a warm and welcoming ambiance. Stay cozy in all seasons with the 2021 installed A/C and furnace, ensuring comfort during hot summers and chilly winters. Enjoy the natural light from newly replaced windows, and admire the crisp, low maintenance siding that enhances both curb appeal and insulation, also added in 2021. Your peace of mind is guaranteed with a new roof and gutter guards. Outside, this property shines with its well-manicured landscaping, creating a serene environment for outdoor activities and a large deck overlooking lake views. Take advantage of the included boat dock and lift at the easement, making water adventures a breeze. For pet owners, the large fenced-in yard provides security and space to play. Store outdoor equipment in the convenient storage shed keeping your garage clutter free. A 24 x 24 attached 2 car garage, offers ample room for vehicles and storage. Having guests? Plenty of parking with the two driveways to park on. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own a beautifully updated lake home with convenient access to Lake Shafer.

3097 E Stahl Road, Monon

Listing courtesy of Nathan Walts from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. 574-583-8181

$369,250
2 Beds 2 Baths 202629863 MLS 1,600 SqFt. Brenda Sprunger
Your Own Private Forest in the Heart of Monticello! Have you ever dreamed of owning your own little forest without giving up the convenience of living in town? This rare 3.33-acre property offers the best of both worlds—peaceful, secluded living right in the heart of Monticello! As you cruise down the private asphalt driveway, you'll arrive at this charming 2-bedroom (with potential for a 3rd bedroom), 1.5-bath home surrounded by mature trees, abundant wildlife, and a stocked pond. The updated kitchen is designed to impress with Samsung Smart appliances, beautiful granite countertops, and soft-close cabinetry and drawers. The inviting living room features a cozy wood-burning fireplace and stunning beam ceilings, creating the perfect place to gather. One of the home's standout features is the wall of windows along the back, offering breathtaking views of your private wooded acreage and tranquil pond. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee or watching deer and other wildlife, every season brings a spectacular view. Step outside onto the spacious deck, ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing in nature. The property also includes an attached 24' x 40' garage and an additional 24' x 25' detached garage, providing plenty of space for vehicles, hobbies, and storage. Properties like this are incredibly hard to find— Close to Lake Freeman & Public boat launch too!

307 S Beach Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Brenda Sprunger from Redlow Group. 765-490-5926

$414,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202629810 MLS 1,765 SqFt. Kimberly Sut
Lake life is calling! This well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect combination of comfortable living, extra storage, and easy access to the water. Situated on one of the largest corner lots in the neighborhood, this property includes two parcels, giving you additional space and private lake access just across the street. Inside, you’ll find a spacious layout featuring a welcoming kitchen with a center island, soft-close cabinetry, updated countertops, and plenty of room for gathering. The primary suite includes a private en-suite bathroom, creating a comfortable retreat at the end of the day. Step outside through the double patio doors to an area complete with an electric awning, making it easy to relax and entertain in nearly any weather. The partially fenced backyard provides room for pets, play, gardening, or outdoor enjoyment. Storage is no issue with an attached 2-car garage plus two additional detached garages/storage buildings, offering space for extra vehicles, boats, recreational equipment, or a workshop. An RV electrical hookup adds even more versatility for campers, motorhomes, or specialty equipment. Just across the street, your second parcel provides access to the lake where you can spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, or simply unwinding by the water. The electric boat lift is already in place—just bring your boat—and the private pier is perfect for casting a line, enjoying the views, or watching the sunset. A charming gazebo creates the ideal spot to relax and take in the peaceful lake scenery. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or the ultimate lake retreat, this property offers an incredible opportunity to enjoy everything lake living has to offer. With so many features and amenities, this home is truly one you need to experience in person. Schedule your private showing today!

5008 E Shady Point Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Kimberly Sut from Listing Leaders Executive Real Estate Group, LLC. 219-669-6081

$425,000
5 Beds 2 Baths 202629534 MLS 5,070 SqFt. Sean Dekker
Timeless charm meets modern comfort in this beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 2-bath Brookston home! Natural woodwork, hardwood floors, and classic craftsmanship create a warm, inviting atmosphere. The charming kitchen offers beautiful finishes, while the main-level primary suite features a walk-in shower. Exceptional storage includes oversized closets, a triple-closet hallway, and a spacious bath with triple sinks. The finished third-floor attic is ideal for a rec room, hobby space, office, or playroom, and the basement provides additional storage. Step outside to your private backyard oasis with an in-ground pool and privacy fence—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The oversized heated 2-car garage features epoxy floors and built-in cabinets. Conveniently located near schools, parks, and local amenities.

400 S Prairie Street, Brookston

Listing courtesy of Sean Dekker from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. 574-583-8181

$329,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202629428 MLS 1,792 SqFt. Chris Thayer
This darling Cape Cod home is on a beautiful, pine-tree-lined lot and has drive-by appeal sure to impress. Situated between Lake Shafer and the Big Monon, you are just a short walk or golf cart ride to your Lake Shafer easement, complete with a slip for your boat. There are three bedrooms, including a main-floor primary bedroom with an attached bath. The living room includes a gas-log fireplace, and the kitchen opens to the deck with a retractable awning. All the appliances, including washer, dryer, and water softener, are included. There is a heated & cooled one-car attached garage, plus a nice 24x30 Morton pole building that is heated and insulated, and even a cute shed, all offering excellent storage for your hobbies and water toys. Best of all, you can be on the water in just a minute!

3997 E First Rd, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Chris Thayer from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-870-1354

$379,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 202629287 MLS 2,330 SqFt. Triva Woodley
Discover the perfect blend of space and functionality on this beautiful 7-acre property. Featuring a pond, two pole buildings, and a lean-to, this property offers endless possibilities for country living and hobbies. This home offers approximately 2,330 sf. of living space with 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths, providing plenty of room for family and guests. The 32'x42' finished pole building includes a full bathroom perfect for entertaining, home office, or additional workspace. An additional 40'x72' pole building features a heated workshop area, which is perfect for projects, equipment storage, or year-around use. If you are looking for a hobby farm or a property with exceptional outbuildings, this has everything you need. Schedule your showing today!

2600 E 1100 N, Monon

Listing courtesy of Triva Woodley from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. triva@vogel-real-estate.com

$299,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202629277 MLS 1,260 SqFt. Rachel Henry
**BUILT IN 2025 | 3 BEDROOMS | 2 BATHROOMS | MODERN FINISHES | NEAR THE RIVER** Welcome home to this beautifully crafted 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch, where quality craftsmanship meets modern design. Located just moments from the river, this move-in-ready home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and convenience. Step inside to discover an open-concept layout filled with natural light, luxury wood-look flooring, and contemporary finishes throughout. The spacious kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring crisp white shaker cabinetry, contrasting dark lower cabinets, stainless steel appliances, a large center island with seating, and abundant counter space—perfect for entertaining or everyday living. The private primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a beautifully appointed en-suite bathroom featuring a double-sink vanity and generous storage. Two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office, while the second full bath showcases stylish modern finishes. Additional highlights include a dedicated laundry room with built-in cabinetry and folding counter, a high-efficiency HVAC system, durable low-maintenance flooring throughout, and ample storage. Outside, enjoy the welcoming front porch with modern railing and the rear deck, providing the perfect space for morning coffee, grilling, or relaxing while taking in the peaceful surroundings near the river. Whether you're looking for your first home, downsizing into low-maintenance living, or searching for a brand-new investment, this thoughtfully designed home checks all the boxes.

714 Bluewater Court, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Rachel Henry from Modern Real Estate. Cell: 574-732-4889

$429,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 202629252 MLS 2,051 SqFt. Nathan Walts
Enjoy panoramic views of Lake Shafer from the open concept kitchen, dining, and living areas of this spacious 2,051 sq ft, 4 bed, 2 bath ranch. The primary suite offers comfort and convenience, while new flooring gives the home a fresh, modern feel. Step outside to the covered lakeside patio with low maintenance composite decking, relax in the hot tub, and take in the waterfront scenery. A new pier and steel seawall make it easy to enjoy boating, fishing, and all that lake life has to offer. The attached 2.5 car garage includes a tandem parking bay, providing space for a third vehicle, golf cart, or extra storage. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or the perfect lake retreat, this Lake Shafer home delivers comfort, functionality, and exceptional waterfront living. Perfect location to fish, kayak, paddle board and float or just relax and take in those fantastic lake views!

6767 N 300 E, Monon

Listing courtesy of Nathan Walts from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. 574-583-8181

$339,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202629102 MLS 1,804 SqFt. Paula Brooks
Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath home located in the desirable Royal Oaks Subdivision! This move-in ready home features a spacious 1 1/2 car attached garage with storage and an inviting layout designed for comfortable living. The stunning custom kitchen boasts quartz countertops, laminate floors, and quality finishes that make it the heart of the home. Both bathrooms have been tastefully updated, offering modern style and convenience. Enjoy relaxing or entertaining in the spacious screened-in porch, offering the perfect place to unwind while enjoying the outdoors. Additional recent improvements include a new roof and new gutters, both installed in 2024, providing added peace of mind. This beautifully maintained home is ready for its next owner—don't miss your opportunity to make it yours!

1633 N Royal Oaks Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Paula Brooks from Redlow Group. 765-490-5926

$429,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202628697 MLS 1,730 SqFt. Matt Zook
Welcome to lake living at its finest! This beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath home on picturesque Lake Shafer has been updated from top to bottom, offering the perfect blend of modern comfort and waterfront charm. The spacious floor plan features a huge family room with stunning views of the water, creating the ideal space to relax or entertain family and friends. The impressive kitchen showcases new appliances, solid surface countertops, and stylish finishes, while new flooring throughout the home gives it a fresh, contemporary feel. Major updates provide peace of mind, including all new mechanicals within the past couple of years, an on-demand water heater, whole-home water filtration system, and a whole-home generator. Outside, you'll appreciate the oversized 2-car garage with plenty of space for a workshop, hobbies, or extra storage. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence or the perfect weekend retreat, this move-in-ready Lake Shafer home offers exceptional quality, thoughtful updates, and the waterfront lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Schedule your private showing today and experience everything this incredible property has to offer!

6551 N 300 E, Monon

Listing courtesy of Matt Zook from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. cell: 574-229-0938

$412,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 202628586 MLS 4,252 SqFt. Sherry Cole
Welcome to this 4 bedroom, 3 bath home in the desirable Brookston area! This well-maintained ranch home offers the perfect blend of convenience and country living, situated on a spacious .82-acre lot with a peaceful rural setting while still being close to everyday amenities. The inviting main level features comfortable living space, and the full basement provides excellent potential for additional living area, storage, or future finishing. Recent updates include a roof that is only 3 years old and a furnace that is approximately 6 years old, offering peace of mind for years to come. Enjoy the privacy of a larger lot, mature surroundings, and the ease of a convenient location. A great opportunity to own a ranch home with acreage in a sought-after area!

10991 S State Rd 43, Brookston

Listing courtesy of Sherry Cole from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 765-426-9442

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated